Why Is Vanilla So Expensive?

"Plain vanilla" is supposed to mean ordinary. Real vanilla is anything but. After saffron, it's often called the most expensive spice in the world, and a single bean can cost more than a pint of ice cream. Here's why, and what it has to do with the soap in your shower.

The short answer

Vanilla is expensive because it's slow and hard to grow. It comes from an orchid whose flowers open for about a day and, outside its native Mexico, must be pollinated by hand, one flower at a time. The beans take about nine months to ripen and several more months to cure. Most of the world's supply comes from one country, Madagascar, so storms, poor harvests and theft can send prices soaring. Most "vanilla" flavor and scent you encounter is actually vanillin made in a lab.

It comes from a fussy orchid

Vanilla beans are the seed pods of the vanilla orchid, a climbing vine native to Mexico and Central America. The plant takes about three years to flower for the first time. When it does, each flower opens in the morning and closes by evening. If it isn't pollinated in that window, there's no bean.

In Mexico, a native bee does the job, at least some of the time. Everywhere else, people do. Growers walk the vines every morning during the flowering season and pollinate each blossom by hand with a small stick or a thumbnail.

A 12-year-old figured out the trick

For centuries, vanilla vines planted outside Mexico grew happily but rarely made beans. In 1841, on the French island of Réunion in the Indian Ocean, a 12-year-old enslaved boy named Edmond Albius worked out a quick way to hand-pollinate the flowers by lifting a thin flap inside the bloom and pressing the parts together. His method is still how almost all of the world's vanilla is pollinated today. Albius himself received little credit or reward during his lifetime.

Then you wait, and wait

A pollinated flower becomes a green pod that takes about nine months to mature. Green vanilla beans have almost no vanilla smell. The flavor develops during curing, a process that can take several months.

  • Killing. The beans are dipped in hot water or heated to stop them growing.
  • Sweating. They're wrapped in blankets or boxes to sweat, then laid in the sun by day. This is when they turn brown and the vanillin forms.
  • Drying. They dry slowly on racks for weeks.
  • Conditioning. Finally, they rest in closed boxes for months so the flavor rounds out.

It takes several pounds of green beans to make one pound of cured vanilla. Every step is done by hand.

One country grows most of it

Madagascar grows most of the world's vanilla, and the rest comes from places like Indonesia, Mexico, Uganda, Papua New Guinea and Tahiti. When most of a crop comes from one island, anything that happens there moves the global price. In 2017, a powerful cyclone hit Madagascar's main vanilla region, and over the next year prices climbed to several hundred dollars a kilogram, more than silver by weight. Prices have come down since, but they still swing with each harvest.

High prices bring their own problems. Vanilla theft became common enough that some farmers brand their beans with their own markings and guard their vines at night. Some growers pick early to beat thieves, which means lower quality beans.

So what's in my vanilla ice cream?

Probably not much real vanilla. Most of the vanilla flavor sold around the world is vanillin, the main flavor compound in vanilla beans, made from other sources such as wood pulp byproducts and petrochemicals. It's widely estimated that less than 1% of vanilla flavor comes from actual beans. Real vanilla contains hundreds of other flavor compounds too, which is why pure extract tastes rounder and more complex than imitation.

Vanilla in soap

Vanilla is one of the most loved scents in soap, and it comes with a quirk every soapmaker learns the hard way. Vanillin turns soap brown. A bar scented with vanilla, or with any fragrance containing vanillin, will slowly darken over days and weeks, from cream to tan to chocolate. It doesn't change how the soap works. It just looks different.

That's why vanilla bars are often brown on purpose, or why soapmakers use a stabilizer or keep the vanilla in one layer of a bar. It's also why a fragrance that smells like cupcakes might turn a white bar the color of coffee.

Real vanilla beans and pure vanilla extract rarely go into soap, by the way. They're expensive, and their scent doesn't survive the soapmaking process very well. Soapmakers use vanilla fragrance oils instead, which hold up in the bar and in the shower.

Our vanilla bar

Our Mother-In-Law's Favorite is layered black raspberry, vanilla and champagne. Sweet, a little celebratory, and a crowd favorite in gift baskets. Like all our traditional bars, it's made with organic oils and phthalate-free fragrance. For a cozier sweet scent, browse our honey soaps, or see the whole soap shelf.

Curious about the other things that go into a bar? Read what is soap made of, or how scent families work in masculine scents, explained.

Questions people ask

Why is vanilla so expensive?

Vanilla orchids must be pollinated by hand outside Mexico, the beans take about nine months to grow and months to cure, and most of the world's supply comes from Madagascar, so bad weather and theft move prices.

Why does vanilla turn soap brown?

Vanillin, the main scent compound in vanilla, darkens in soap over days and weeks. It doesn't change how the soap works, only how it looks.

Who discovered how to hand-pollinate vanilla?

Edmond Albius, a 12-year-old enslaved boy on the island of Réunion, in 1841. His method is still used to pollinate nearly all vanilla today.

Restocks and new posts

Hear first when a sold-out bar is back, plus new posts from the journal.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.